Timed quizzes - yay or nay?

I’ve never been sold on timed quizzes. Every time a stakeholder asks for a countdown on the final assessment “so people can’t google the answers,” I end up in the same place. We’ve swapped a test of whether someone can do the job for a test of how fast they read under pressure, and the people it punishes are the careful readers, the anxious ones and anyone working in their second language. None of that has much to do with competency. I’m not completely stubborn about it though. There are definitely cases where speed is the skill, like emergency procedures or anything where hesitating on the job is a real risk, so I’m curious where other people draw the line.

2 Likes

The googling thing is what gets me. If they can google it in 30 seconds it’s probably a recall question.Most of that stuff they could look it up on the job anyway, so I’d rather fix the questions than add a clock.

Only time I’d leave a timer on is if the standard actually says it has to be done in a set time, otherwise the clock is testing something that isn’t in the outcome. Pretty sure WCAG has something about time limits needing to be adjustable too unless the timing is essential, 2.2.1 I think.

The bit I’m not sure about is the stuff people do need to know cold without looking it up. Does anyone time that..and if so how do you decide what the limit should be?

1 Like

Such good points from you both!

I’m leaning nay as well. I did have a bit of a look around though and couldn’t find anything showing a timer actually stops people looking up the answers, so I’m with @Rosabirg on fixing the questions first. For the things people need to know cold, it seems like the areas where hesitating is a real risk tend to time the doing, not a quiz. CPR is a good example, the compressions have a time window and going too fast fails as well.

Also curious if anyone has tried getting a few people who already know the content to sit the quiz first, then setting the limit from how long they take? That’s probably where I’d start, but I’m not sure how much extra you’d add on top.